Maggie Bowers thinks she knows what to expect her junior year of high school--yeah, it would be nice if her mother didn't care so much about her weight, but at least she has Nash, her out-of-the-closet best friend and a cool afterschool job at the local record store. But when Tom moves to town at the start of the school year they have something unexpected in common--feelings for the same guy. Up until now Maggie and Nash they have always chosen each other, but what if winning someone's heart means losing their soul mate?